Go to the U of M home page.

Home > McGee Moot Court > Past Results > 2002-2003

2002-2003 Competition Results

2002-2003 HIGHLIGHTS

"Do Democracy and Justice Exist in Secret?
The Constitutionality of Blanket Closure of Deportation Hearings
in the Wake of 9/11."

 

 Moot Court Winners
Final panel members Chief Judge Hansen and Hennepin County District Court Judge Lloyd B. Zimmerman are flanked on the left by the winners of the William E. McGee National Civil Rights Moot Court Competition, Devon Cornell, who also won Best Oral Advocate Over-all, and Jenny-Brook Condon of Seton Hall School of Law, and on the right by Hannah Buch and Anissa Floyd of the Second Place team from Tulane Law School.

 

The Eighteenth Annual William E. McGee National Civil Rights Moot Court Competition was held February 27-28, and March 1, 2003 at the University of Minnesota Law School. Thirty-three teams representing the following law schools participated:

University of Baltimore School of Law
Brooklyn Law School
Campbell University School of Law
DePaul University College of Law
George Mason Univ. School of Law
Georgia State University College of Law
Hamline University School of Law
Mercer Law School
University of Minnesota Law School
Moritz College of Law, Ohio State Univ.
New York University School of Law
New York Law School
Northeastern Univ. School of Law
University of Oregon School of Law
Santa Clara Law School
Seton Hall School of Law
Stetson University College of Law
Temple Univ. Beasley School of Law
Tulane Law School
Villanova School of Law
Whittier Law School
Widener University School of Law
William Mitchell College of Law
University of Wisconsin Law School

The competition focused on the conflict between our need for heightened security in the wake of 9/11, and our desires to preserve individual liberties and an open society. Each team briefed and argued Detroit Free Press v. Ashcroft, 303 F.3d 681 (6th Cir. 2002) in which the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals held that the First Amendment of the United States' Constitution provides the public and the press with a right of access to deportation hearings, and Haddad v. Ashcroft, 221 F. Supp. 2d 799 (E.D. Mich. 2002), in which a district court in the Sixth Circuit ruled that INS detainees have a right to public deportation hearings pursuant to the Fifth Amendment.

The Honorable David R. Hansen, Chief Judge of the United States Court of Appeals Eighth Circuit, Justice John E. Simonett of the Minnesota Supreme Court (retired) and Judges E. Anne McKinsey and Lloyd Zimmerman of the Hennepin County District Court presided over the final argument in Lockhart Hall.

Seton Hall School of Law won First Place. Tulane Law School came in second. Brooklyn Law School won Third Place. Mercer Law School Team 1 finished fourth and won Best Brief honors. Devon Corneal of Seton Hall School of Law won Best Oral Advocate Over-All with Matt Talcott of George Mason University School of Law receiving an honorable mention. Joseph Rich of Villanova School of Law Team 1 won Best Oral Advocate of the Preliminary Rounds.

Other teams that advanced to the Quarter-Finals included: University of Minnesota Law School Team 2, George Mason University School of Law, New York University School of Law and Hamline University School of Law Team 2. Other teams that advanced to the Round of Sixteen included: Campbell University School of Law Team 1, University of Wisconsin Law School Team 2, DePaul University College of Law, Hamline University School of Law Team 1, New York Law School, Stetson, University of Minnesota Law School Team 1 and Northeastern University School of Law Team 2.

Over 130 members of the bar and bench volunteered to judge briefs, oral arguments or both. Prior to the competition, the Civil Rights Moot Court offered the volunteer judges a free Continuing Legal Education program, "Do Democracy and Justice Exist in Secret? The Constitutionality of Blanket Closure of Deportation Hearings in the Wake of 9/11." The program included a panel discussion regarding the legal, constitutional and policy issues involved in cases like Detroit Free Press and North Jersey Media Group, Inc. v. Ashcroft, 308 F.3d 198 (3rd Cir.2002), a conflicting decision from the Third Circuit. The panel consisted of Professor Adam Samaha, a visiting scholar at the law school, Professor Jayanth K. Krishnan of William Mitchell College of Law, Karen Ellingson, Esq., Legal Work Coordinator of the Immigrant Law Center of Minnesota and Adjunct Director of the law school's Immigration Clinic, and Terry M. Louie, Esq., Assistant District Counsel of the St. Paul District Office of the U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service. Clinical Professor Carl Warren moderated the panel. Professor Raliegh Hanna Levine of William Mitchell College of Law spoke concerning the standards and the appropriate analysis of constitutional claims in cases like Detroit Free Press. Professor Maury Landsman, of the University of Minnesota Law School, discussed the distinction between confidentiality and privilege.

 

 Moot Court Winners
The Honorable David R. Hansen, Chief Judge of the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals and Dean Alex M. Johnson, Jr. present William E. McGee National Civil Rights Moot Court Competition Third Place honors to the Rachel Wrightson, Jaclyn Braunstein and Rachel Braunstein team from Brooklyn Law School.

 

 


 
Chief Judge Hansen and Judge Zimmerman present Best Brief honors to Bryan Bates, Chris Harne and Joel Brown of Mercer Law School Team 1, which also won Fourth Place.

 

 


 
Faculty Advisor Carl Warren congratulates Matt Talcott of George Mason University School of Law on receiving honorable mention for finishing a close second in the Best Oral Advocate Over-all competition.

 

 


 
Chief Judge Hansen and Judge Zimmerman pose with Best Oral Advocate of the Preliminary Rounds winner Joseph Rich and his coach Danielle Joffee. Mr. Rich was a member of Villanova School of Law Team 1.

 

 
Rose McGee, widow of competition namesake, William E. McGee, welcomed competition participants at the opening banquet and gave a stirring reading of her poem, "I Remember Exactly Where I Was (A Tribute to The Wellstones and All The Warriors)".

 

 
Jazz keyboardist, Larry McDonough, entertains McGee Competition participants at the opening banquet. Larry McDonough is the adjunct Director of the University of Minnesota Law School's Housing Clinic.